I'm With Geek
  • Home
  • Geekery
    • TGH
    • Creative
    • IWGCast
  • Film
    • The Essentials
    • Hit Play/Hit Stop
    • Trailer Parks
  • TV
  • Games
  • Comics
  • Books
  • About
  • Our Team
  • Contact
  • Editors Blog

Doctor Who: Who is Clara Oswald?

5/17/2013

 
Picture
By Matthew Battles

Clara, the girl who has died twice and met the Doctor thrice. The mystery “squeezed into an enigma wrapped in a skirt that’s just a little bit too... tight.” You’ve had Whovians up and down the nation, and across the Pond (too soon?) all asking the same question as our favorite Timelord; “What are you?”

With the finale of season 7 just a single sleep away, it won’t be long before the mystery is solved and we’ll finally know, but just what are the possibilities? With Steven Moffat at the helm they’re seemingly infinite but we’ve got some theories. From the perfectly plausible and most likely, to the outright outlandish, we’ve laid them out for your perusal.

Picture
Clara is a Fixed/Recurring Point in Time and Space.

Similarly to Captain Jack Harkness, made immortal by the actions of Rose Tyler, Clara may have found herself embroiled in some future Bad Wolf-like crisis that caused her to somehow join with, or look into, the heart of the TARDIS and the trauma of the event caused her consciousness to scatter across time and space, leaving pieces of herself for the Doctor to find, become intrigued by and follow to the original source - the Clara we have come to have sitting in Sexy right now - and setting this whole chain of events into motion. We all know just how much Moffat loves his Paradoxes!

Picture
Clara is a manifestation of the Great Intelligence

It can’t just be a coincidence that Clara rocked up around about the same time the Great Intelligence reared its ugly metaphysical head again. Her entire premier episode, The Snowmen (let’s be honest the Asylum of the Daleks was more of a teaser than an introduction) was almost entirely about the Great Intelligence. Not to mention the Great Intelligence was behind all the goings on at the Shard too.

It can’t be that much of a leap to assume that at some point in the future the Great Intelligence finally found itself a way to manifest into physical form. If that were the case surely the Doctor would be involved somehow? The fields of Tranzalore perhaps? We already know that the Great Intelligence will also feature in the finale so it’s safe to assume it’s involvement in some capacity.

Now all that the Great Intelligence would have to do is lead the Doctor back to where everything began by leaving ‘sleeper Clara’s’ all over the universe to set everything in motion in a Moffet-esque Paradox.

Let’s not forget that Clara seems almost instantly adept at doing just about anything. She went from a technophobe who couldn’t access the Wifi to a hoverbike-riding superhero in a mere two episodes. If that wasn’t enough, doesn’t her sudden transformation into a battle-hardened Major last week prove that Clara has a Great Intelligence of her own somewhere in there?

Picture
Clara is a fragment of the exploding TARDIS

Don’t forget we haven’t finished unravelling the mystery of the exploding TARDIS yet. We know that’s going to happen somewhen but when exactly, who knows! Now, we’ve seen the Doctor himself pull a piece of Sexy out of the crack. What’s to say that other pieces of the TARDIS have fallen through of their own accord?

Perhaps in another timeline the TARDIS’ consciousness was poured, not into Idriss, but that universe’s version of Clara. Who, once on our side of the crack, retained some portion of her time and space traveling abilities but the trauma of such an event leaves the poor girl disorientated and unable to remember anything about who she really is or what she’s done.

Think of her first appearance, in Dalek form, as her final moments. How poetic would it be that the TARDIS, the Doctor’s longest serving companion and best, best friend is transformed into one of his archenemies only to use that transformation against them?

Clara being a piece of the TARDIS might explain two other niggles as well. first of all, it would explain why Sexy doesn’t like her; this TARDIS is fully-formed and hasn’t exploded yet. This TARDIS will recognize a foreign body that’s a piece of itself. Something that shouldn’t possibly exist. It would also explain why a preview photo shows Clara with something that looks suspiciously like the Sixth Doctor behind her. Fractured memories of her time as the TARDIS.

Picture
Clara is another Timelord

There are other Timelords out there, and some of them were much better at being Timelords than the Doctor. Sorry guys but he said it himself last week; “You should see the state of these neurons, he’s had some cowboys in here. Ten complete rejigs.”

You see, regeneration shouldn’t be as difficult or as altering as it for the Doctor. There should actually be a modicum of control over the proceedings. Some Timelords were so adept at regeneration they could not only do it at will on a whim, but also had some choice in the end result; take Romana for example, she went through several faces before sticking with one that she liked. The fact that the Doctor’s entire face, and personality, is completely altered by the process only serves to highlight his ineptitude.

What are the odds that Clara is a Timelord who is not only extremely good at regenerating that she’s able to maintain the same face throughout but can also allow her body to appear to shut down before the process begins? It’s not the most realistic of possibilities but a possibility nonetheless.

Picture
Clara is The Doctor and River’s daughter

Not my favorite theory but I suppose there’s a hint of credence to it. For a start she’s very similar to the Doctor in a lot of ways. She also has signs of River’s psychopathic ferocity (anyone else remember just how comfortable was waving that big-ass gun around last week?). It would also serve to explain why she’s such a clever clogs. She’d have a Timelord brain for sure!

Let’s not forget that she is, to all intents and purposes, human. This would be explained through River’s genetics. Despite having a third helix as a result of being conceived in the TARDIS, River is human. With human DNA which means some of that would have, along with some ability to regenerate (maybe with a single fixed form perhaps?), been passed along to Clara.

I also feel there was something significant in the throwaway lines from previous episodes; The Rings of Akhaten; “I came here once with my Granddaughter,” Hide; “blood calling to blood, out of time. Not everything ends, not always.” Could it be that he’s now whizzing around the universe with his best mates’ Granddaughter?

Picture
Clara is C.A.L

Last and least likely, Clara is C.A.L. Anyone confused? Remember the little girl in the command node at the library? Yeah that one. A lot of people are saying that Jenna-Louise Coleman bears a strong resemblance to Eve Newton who played C.A.L herself. A lot of people are wondering if she and River have found a way to bust out of the library and are preparing a dramatic way of letting the Doctor in on the secret?

Don’t forget the words she said to River when she first found herself in library-ville; “I’ve brought along a few friends. Who’s a CLEVER girl?” Which is a word that frequently arises with Clara; “Run you CLEVER boy, and remember.” Remember what? The little girl who needed help all those centuries ago perhaps?

Personally, I’m not buying it, but I thought it was worth a mention.

Whatever the truth is, we don’t have long to wait. My money’s on it being one of the first three. Who knows, some people think she might even be a future regeneration of the Doctor. What’re your thoughts on the identity of Clara? Agree with me? Got your own theory? Lets us know below!

Picture

Comments are closed.


    TV Editor: Graham Osborne
    Picture

    TV 

    Reviews on the best TV has to offer, as well as retrospective looks at the shows of yesteryear we miss so much. 

    Regular features include: 

    Have you seen...? - We take a look at TV shows you may not have seen, but should really check out?
    Retrospectives - We look back the shows that have ended.
    From the Trenches - Matthew Howe shares his hilarious experiences from the Trenches of the Media Industry.
    Catch it on Catch-Up - A run down of some quality TV that you may have missed first time around.
    Turn Off - The very worst that television has to offer.
    Doctor Who - The latest News, Reviews and features on the 50 year sci-fi giant!

    Email: tv@imwithgeek.com

    Categories

    All
    12-monkeys
    Adventure-time
    Agent Carter
    Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.
    AKA Jessica Jones
    Alex Doust
    Almost-human
    Amazon Instant
    Amazon Studios
    American Horror Story
    Arrow
    Atlantis
    Avatar The Last Airbender
    BAFTA
    Banshee
    Bates Motel
    Batman
    BBC
    Ben Mapp
    Beth Rogers
    Better Call Saul
    Big Bang Theory
    Black Mirror
    Boardwalk Empire
    Breaking Bad
    Bring Back...
    Britta Lundin
    Broadchurch
    Callum Armour
    Catch It On Catch Up
    Catfish
    Catherine Wignall
    Chasing Life
    Childhood Tv
    Christian Kern
    Christmas
    Community
    Companion Faceoff
    Constantine
    Cookie N Screen
    Cookie N Screen
    Coupling
    Critics Choice Awards
    Cuckoo
    Cucumberbananatofu
    Daniel-franco
    Daredevil
    David Tennant
    Detestable Tv
    Dexter
    Discworld
    Doctor Who
    Doctor Who
    Downton Abbey
    Dracula
    DVD
    E4
    Elementary
    Emmy Awards
    Essentials
    Family Guy
    Fargo
    Father's Day
    Finale
    Firefly
    Flash
    Friends
    From The Trenches
    From The Trenches
    Galavant
    Game Of Thrones
    Game Of Thrones
    Gemma Williams
    Gemma-williams
    Georgia Thompson
    Girls
    Gloria Danielsmoss
    Gloria Daniels Moss
    Gotham
    Graeme-stirling
    Graham Osborne
    Graham Osborne
    Gravity Falls
    Grimm
    Halloween
    Hannibal
    HAPPYish
    Have You Seen
    Have You Seen...?
    Hayley Charlesworth
    Hayley-charlesworth
    Hbo
    Heather Stromski
    Helen Fulton
    Helen Langdon
    Helen Langdon
    Heroes-reborn
    Hitchhikers-guide-to-the-galaxy
    Homeland
    House
    House Of Cards
    How I Met Your Mother
    ICYMI
    In Memoriam
    Inside-no9
    Interview
    In The Flesh
    I Survived The Zombie Apocalypse
    IZombie
    Jack Edwards
    James Morgans
    Jamie Kennett
    Jane The Virgin
    Jenny Mullinder
    Jo Johnstone
    Josh Crooks
    Julia Lawson
    Kim J Osborne
    Laura Weaver
    Leah Stone
    Leah Stone
    Legends Of Tomorrow
    Liam-bland
    Liam Murphy
    Mad Men
    Mahesh Subramaniam
    Marvel
    Matthew Battles
    Matthew Howe
    Max Bosshart
    Melissa Haggar
    Melissa Haggar
    Michael Wilkinson
    Monty Python
    Movies In Motion
    National Towel Day
    Netflix
    New Tricks
    No Spoilers Please
    Once Upon A Time
    Orange Is The New Black
    Orphan Black
    OUAT
    Outlander
    Paul Costello
    Paul Robert Scott
    Phineas And Ferb
    Quiz
    Red Dwarf
    Retrospective
    Ripper Street
    Robbie Jones
    Robbie Jones
    Scott And Bailey
    Scream
    Sense8
    Shakespeare Day
    Sherlock
    Sherlock Holmes
    Sherlock Week
    Sleepy Hollow
    Sons Of Liberty
    Spin-Out!
    Star Trek
    Star-wars
    Star Wars Rebels
    St Patrick's Day
    Supernatural
    Teen Wolf
    Teen Wolf
    The 100
    The Box Set
    The Flash
    The Following
    The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air
    The Hour
    The Leftovers
    The Musketeers
    The Musketeers
    The Office
    The Originals
    The Originals
    The Simpsons
    The Sopranos
    The Spider
    The Tomorrow People
    The Vampire Diaries
    The-vampire-diaries
    The Walking Dead
    This-week
    Timmy Time
    Tomas Keavney
    Tom Sams
    Trends-in-tv
    True Blood
    True Detective
    Turn-off
    TV Awards
    Tv Intros
    Tv-intros
    TV Teaser
    TV Teasers
    TV Teasers
    Twin Peaks
    Valentine's Day
    Veep
    Verushka-byrow
    Vikings
    William John
    William John
    Witches Of East End
    Wizards Vs Aliens
    Wolfblood
    Xavier Gonne
    You Should Be Watching

    Archives

    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.