I'm With Geek
  • Home
  • Geekery
    • TGH
    • Creative
    • IWGCast
  • Film
    • The Essentials
    • Hit Play/Hit Stop
    • Trailer Parks
  • TV
  • Games
  • Comics
  • Books
  • About
  • Our Team
  • Contact
  • Editors Blog

Review: Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Volume 3

1/23/2015

 
PicturePretty Guardian Sailor Moon Volume 3 (click for source)
by Gemma Williams

Volume three, headed by the beautiful Sailor Mars, covers acts twelve to sixteen of the overall story. It carries on from the previous book which finished on a cliff-hanger, as the Scouts discovered some treacherous, yet glaringly obvious, news. The series has had a lot of action, romance and fantasy elements incorporated so far; what more can you ask for?

PictureClick for source
The book begins with everyone’s reaction to the news at the end of volume two. The end of the first story arch is nearing a close and it is wrapped up within two to three acts. The next arc begins after some hefty sacrifices and heart-breaking scenes.

My main issue with this series is that the story moves too fast. The panels will jump from one scene to another with no warning, missing out a large time frame. Many manga that I have read in the past is better paced and planned whereas this just seems impulsive. A fast paced story can be good, but not this quick! I want to enjoy the story and the characters more. The character development for everyone but Usagi has been frustratingly slow and they just feel like they are there to bolster the Princess when she is down or needs protecting, when really they are intended to be just as important as she. Usagi is whiny and spoilt; at least I can’t complain that she’s a Mary-Sue character as she certainly is not. She does have a lot of good points too, but they’re not quite interesting or strong enough to compete with the annoying.

Something that has been prominent and highly surprising in these three volumes is how secretive, yet conspicuous, the girls have been over their identities. First of all, they look exactly the same as Scouts as they do when they are human, yet no one figures this out. Could Takeuchi really not give them more imaginative costumes or disguises? While transformed, they don’t refer to each other as their Scout name, but their human name, in front of the enemies and their friends, yet no one cottons on except for the odd exception. There are even a few students from another school that have noticed the gang together a lot and suspect them of keeping a secret, so their secret identities are really not that safe or secure.

PictureClick for source
As always, the cover and first few pages are vibrant with colour and printed on good quality paper. Seeing the characters in colour images is a treat as they are drawn and coloured in so beautifully that you will struggle to take your eyes off the pages as you admire the intricate art work and detail that goes into making the characters look real.

The next story arch is irritating so far as there has been a character introduced who is even more infuriating than Usagi, but hopefully they will calm down soon and stop being such an unnecessary pain. As with many different books, films and stories, the character refuses to tell anyone what is happening and so they are fighting in the dark. If they just opened up from the start, instead of being obnoxious, they would have been offered help and would probably have been able to prevent a lot of tragedies.

Volume three also ended on a cliff hanger, though what manga doesn’t? Volume four is sitting on my shelf waiting to be picked up and for the story to continue. Mangas are quick, fun reads and Sailor Moon is no exception so far, though it really is a lot darker than I realised as I witnessed parallels within the story with Disney’s Beauty and the Beast and with Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet.


Comments are closed.

    Comics

    Comics are this section's passion, both those obscure and those in fashion. Whether Marvel, Dark Horse or D.C, we've got it all, just come and see!



    Picture
    Comics Editor
     Sarah Wagner

    [email protected]

    Categories

    All
    Aaron Nash
    Alex Thomas
    Andy Williams
    Batman
    Bob Bruno
    Boom
    Cherean-ashley
    Chris-davidson
    Cookie N Screen
    Dark Horse
    Dc Comics
    Dynamite
    Emlyn Roberts Harry
    Emlyn Roberts-Harry
    Gavin Foo
    Gemma Williams
    Hayley Charlesworth
    Idw Publishing
    Image Comics
    Independent
    Indie Fiction Triple Feature
    Interview
    Jacob H Baxter
    Jade Lindley
    Jake Douglas
    Josh Crooks
    Lewis E. Ryan
    Manga
    Marvel
    Musomic
    Perth Comics Centre
    Pipedream
    Ross Antony Barnard
    Sam Hurcom
    Sarah Turner
    Sarah Wagner
    Tiff Douglas
    Top Cow
    T Pub
    Vertigo
    Weekly Roundup

    Archives

    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    March 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.