I'm With Geek
  • Home
  • Geekery
    • TGH
    • Creative
    • IWGCast
  • Film
    • The Essentials
    • Hit Play/Hit Stop
    • Trailer Parks
  • TV
  • Games
  • Comics
  • Books
  • About
  • Our Team
  • Contact
  • Editors Blog

Valentine's Day: It's a Kind of Magic

2/14/2015

 
PictureClick for Source Image
by Gemma Williams

It's a Kind of Magic by Carole Matthews is a romance novel with a magical twist, as it is aptly named. The story, however, was not what I expected based on the blurb. The colourful, romantic and magical cover drew me in and promised intrigue. I couldn't wait to read it, but was I in for a surprise.

PictureClick for Source Image
Leo and Emma have been in a serious, on-off relationship for several years, but after one particularly disastrous night at Emma's thirtieth birthday party with her family, things seem to be over for good. A heavily inebriated Leo leaves the party and runs into a suicidal woman, about to jump off a bridge. Everything changes from there.

The magical element to this story felt forced and shallow. There was really very little point to it and certain occurrences, such as Emma's mysterious date, were never fully explained.  While reading, you can almost predict the scenes which compelled the author to pen this as they are beautifully described and are not quite as rushed as the rest of it. Both of these scenes are magical and explains the presence of Isobel in this book. 

There were a few attempts at humour but these felt contrived. There is a skill to writing comedy and sadly, Carole Matthews does not have it. They were tired, old jokes and the speech would feel like it was put there specifically so she could slip the joke in somewhere. They were not funny, clever or entertaining. Grant and Lard (whose real name no one can recall) are supposed to be the funny side characters, there to relieve the tension. However, when they are told outright what Isobel is and then ignore the impossible things that happen in front of their eyes, they quickly become the bumbling fools.

I developed little attachment to the characters and so found it difficult to care about what happened to them. I forced myself to read this because I hate leaving books unfinished. Leo was the stereotypical boyfriend who loves alcohol and partying, yet has a messy house and a lazy demeanour. Emma is the stereotypical over controlling, perfectionist girlfriend. This made the characters unlikeable, annoying and flat. Whereas Leo shows some magical character development, Emma barely changes. She will acknowledge that perhaps she is not perfect and may have contributed to the problems in the relationship, and the next she will be as stubborn, snobby and dominating as ever. The characters are inconsistent as Emma tries to surprise Leo to win him back, but her surprise is extreme and completely unlike her character. Leo makes the biggest change but again, this will differ between scenes.

And then there is the character of Isobel. She was basically a magical sex icon. Men treated her like an object and the only thing she had to establish herself as a character was her magic and the fact that she left glitter everywhere all the time. Other than having magic, who is she? Her reason for coming to Leo was shallow and yet Leo was obsessed with her immediately. The finale was disappointing when Leo still seems to be in love with, and unwilling to leave, Isobel, and so Emma becomes second prize. How insulting is that to every woman who isn't a gorgeous, magical creature? 

The story was a quick, fairly easy read as Matthew's writing style was simple yet engaging. Emma's chapters were written in first person narrative whereas Leo's were in third person. Emma is therefore narrating this tale, yet Leo has more focus, and also cannot tell Emma what actually happened while they were separated but he promised to reveal his story when they were old; so either this was Emma retelling the story when she's old or this was a missed point. If Emma is retelling the story when old, from what Leo has told her, how reliable is the story really?

Matthews wrote incredibly irritating and shallow characters whose back story she clearly came up with on the spot and followed through with for lack of a more imaginative idea. The concept was fascinating and enough to make me pick up the book and push myself to read it, but it was nothing like I expected from the cover and blurb and was a disappointment. I feel like this was a missed opportunity. Do I regret reading it? No. Despite the bad characters and highly flawed story, such as Leo telling his best two 'lad' friends about Isobel's magic despite expressly being told not and them missing out obvious clues, it was an enjoyable read if you can pull yourself away from the ridiculousness of it. But then, what did I expect when I bought it as part of a 'six for £10' deal?


Comments are closed.

    Books

    This section includes Reviews and Articles on the Literature that you'll love from our talented writers at I'm With Geek!



    Picture
    Picture
    Head of Books
    Gemma Williams

    Assistant Editor
    Olivia Grey

    Email: [email protected]

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Categories

    All
    Agnieszka Ramian
    Anna Lee
    A Novel Idea
    Author Corner
    Becks Dawe
    Ben Mapp
    Best Of 2014
    Between The Sheets
    Between The Sheets
    Black History Month
    Book Events
    Book Trailers
    Catherine Wignall
    Charlotte Dibley
    Charlotte Fraser
    Classics
    Competitions
    Cookie N Screen
    Cover Off
    Debates
    Discussion
    Douglas Adams
    Easter
    Elevator Pitch
    Ellie Bowker
    Emlyn Roberts Harry
    Emma Raymond
    Fahima Begum
    From Page To Screen
    Gemma Williams
    Gemma Williams
    Georgia Thompson
    Graeme Stirling
    Graham Osborne
    Guest Writers
    Halloween
    Hayley Charlesworth
    Heather Stromski
    Helen Langdon
    In Memoriam
    Interviews
    Irene Kovalyova
    Jacob Baxter
    Jo Johnstone
    Judging A Book By Its Cover
    Kate Sheahan
    Laura W
    Laura W
    Leah Stone
    Leah Stone
    LGBT Month
    Luke-botham
    Mj Rain
    Mother's Day 2015
    News
    Olivia Grey
    One Hit Wonders
    Pamela Banayoti
    Reviews
    Romance-week-2014
    Samantha Payne
    Samantha Payne
    Sarah Wagner
    Something-to-look-forward-to
    Source Material
    St Patrick's Day
    St-patricks-day-2014836e000f69
    The Funny Pages
    The Nanny Book Project
    The Nanny Book Project
    Verushka-byrow
    World-book-day-2014
    World Book Day 2015

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.