I'm With Geek
  • Home
  • Geekery
    • TGH
    • Creative
    • IWGCast
  • Film
    • The Essentials
    • Hit Play/Hit Stop
    • Trailer Parks
  • TV
  • Games
  • Comics
  • Books
  • About
  • Our Team
  • Contact
  • Editors Blog

Review: Howl's Moving Castle (SPOILERS)

1/5/2015

 
PictureOne of Howl's many book covers, much like his variety of doors!
By Gemma Williams

Contrary to my usual reading habits, I first watched Howl's Moving Castle, many years before even acquiring the book. It was weird, random, made little sense, and was absolutely wonderful. My hopes when reading the book would be that there would be some kind of explanation to the story but that it would be equally wonderful and magical.

The story follows young Sophie Hatter who is put under a curse by a witch. She sets out to discover herself and finds a new home in Howl's Moving Castle. Evil rumours are spread about Howl and so she should be wary as she enters the magical, random and utterly ridiculous castle.

PictureHowl's wonderful 'castle' as seen in the film. It doesn't like this on the inside!
The story was as random as the film but didn't feel as such because the story was chronological and explained to some extent unlike the film. The film missed out many important scenes - important because they explained the story - but worked anyhow. Reading the book has given me greater understanding of the film, and gave me hours of untold entertainment and enjoyment. The writing was rather simple, more so that I am usually comfortable with, but it meshed well with the odd story.

The world was indeed full of magic and intrigue. There were moments where Sophie and Michael were trying to catch a falling star, they used one of Howl's inventions to travel quickly (this did not end well for Sophie!), and of people using magic to switch places so that they could follow their dreams. There was a magical contract, a disaster with slime and some terrified spiders. Diana Wynne Jones did an excellent job building the world but could have done to spend some more time on character development. 

Sophie was frustrating as she seemed to have no personality about her and some of the characters were dull and flat whereas others brimmed with life, colour and energy. She seemed to have no fears or cares and just doddled about regardless of the danger she was in. Her reactions were boring and unrealistic. There also appears to be very little build up with the relationship between Howl and Sophie. There's little to no flirting, or even acknowledgement that there could even be a spark between them, and then suddenly, they're together. It felt forced and seemed to appear out of thin air. 

The witch had serious issues as she had a strange Frankenstein like plan for some wizards. This side of the story would have been much more interesting had it not been revealed, and then thwarted, within a matter of pages. So much more could have been done with this plot line, but maybe then then story would have gone from weird and odd to demented and psychotic.

The resolution of the book was anti-climactic and disappointing after such a wonderful tale. A grandiose battle was expected and whereas it tried to deliver, it missed the mark. All the plot lines were tied neatly together at the end, which is always a huge plus, but it was also rather abrupt and I wasn't entirely satisfied. It ended too soon! Fortunately there are another two books in the series that will hopefully give me closure at a later date.

I had never read a Diana Wynne Jones book before and I'm glad I finally picked one up. The covers are beautiful and the stories enveloping and magical; perfect for when you want to get away into another world. I'll definitely be reading more of her books, starting with the remaining two in this series. Ideally, I would be able to read them in a house similar to Howl's castle.


Comments are closed.

    Books

    This section includes Reviews and Articles on the Literature that you'll love from our talented writers at I'm With Geek!



    Picture
    Picture
    Head of Books
    Gemma Williams

    Assistant Editor
    Olivia Grey

    Email: [email protected]

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Categories

    All
    Agnieszka Ramian
    Anna Lee
    A Novel Idea
    Author Corner
    Becks Dawe
    Ben Mapp
    Best Of 2014
    Between The Sheets
    Between The Sheets
    Black History Month
    Book Events
    Book Trailers
    Catherine Wignall
    Charlotte Dibley
    Charlotte Fraser
    Classics
    Competitions
    Cookie N Screen
    Cover Off
    Debates
    Discussion
    Douglas Adams
    Easter
    Elevator Pitch
    Ellie Bowker
    Emlyn Roberts Harry
    Emma Raymond
    Fahima Begum
    From Page To Screen
    Gemma Williams
    Gemma Williams
    Georgia Thompson
    Graeme Stirling
    Graham Osborne
    Guest Writers
    Halloween
    Hayley Charlesworth
    Heather Stromski
    Helen Langdon
    In Memoriam
    Interviews
    Irene Kovalyova
    Jacob Baxter
    Jo Johnstone
    Judging A Book By Its Cover
    Kate Sheahan
    Laura W
    Laura W
    Leah Stone
    Leah Stone
    LGBT Month
    Luke-botham
    Mj Rain
    Mother's Day 2015
    News
    Olivia Grey
    One Hit Wonders
    Pamela Banayoti
    Reviews
    Romance-week-2014
    Samantha Payne
    Samantha Payne
    Sarah Wagner
    Something-to-look-forward-to
    Source Material
    St Patrick's Day
    St-patricks-day-2014836e000f69
    The Funny Pages
    The Nanny Book Project
    The Nanny Book Project
    Verushka-byrow
    World-book-day-2014
    World Book Day 2015

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.